Since August we have recorded conversations with people who advise franchise networks for a living: four consultants, a lawyer and an accountant, plus one with our own technical director. Each is published in full, with the audio and the transcript, and each stays on one subject.
Read one after another, they start to answer each other. A consultant talking about recruitment and a lawyer talking about disputes turn out to be describing the same franchisee from opposite ends of the agreement. This piece puts those answers side by side, under the questions a business owner tends to ask when they first think about franchising. Everything below is the guest’s view, not ours, and each name links to the conversation it came from. Where two of them disagree, we have left it that way.
1. Should I franchise at all?
The answer from every consultant was a version of the same test: franchise something that already works.
Andy Cheetham, who franchised his own family business before advising others, puts profit first. “A business that’s hovering around break-even or losing money, man, that is the worst thing you could possibly franchise.” It has to make money and still have room for the fee a franchisee will pay on top. His second test is whether an ordinary person could run it: a business that depends on the founder’s talent, or takes four or five years to learn, isn’t one.
Ken Rostron adds a length of time. He looks for “a business model with at least 18 to 24 months’ track record”, because a franchisee is being asked to invest in results that can be shown.
Two further checks came from Andy. Own your trademark before you start, because “it’s not their trademark until they’ve got the trademark”. And look at the timing: there is no point franchising something that was a hit ten years ago.
If part of the model still needs work, his advice is to finish it first. “You shouldn’t really be in the sort of phase in your business where you’re still tinkering with it.”
2. What has to be in place, and what does it cost?
Andy counts “about 28 to 30 core things” his firm puts in place before a business becomes a franchise. The ones he names: the fee modelling, a franchise agreement that runs to 40 or 50 pages even when it’s a slim one, possibly a pilot, a prospectus, and a decision on territories.
On cost he was specific. A trademark is “a couple of hundred quid” for one classification. The legal work runs from about £2,500 to £10,000, with five or six thousand typical. His own firm’s fee to design the whole system is £12,500 over eight weeks, less if the owner does part of the work, and about £2,000 for a guided do-it-yourself course. Those are one firm’s prices, quoted by its founder, but they are the only ones anyone has put on the record for us so far.
Ken describes what the plan itself should hold. It “doesn’t have to be War and Peace”, but he expects a 24-month cash flow forecast, an operating statement and the support programme, starting with induction training that “can often take four to six weeks”.
3. Who should my first franchisees be?
This is the question on which the guests agree most, and they arrived at it separately.
Clive Smith, who was franchise director of Dyno-Rod, starts from the wording. “You will not be in the business of selling franchises.” A franchise is granted to someone who fits a written profile, and the profile is the test for every appointment, including the ones where the candidate is holding out the money. The cost of getting it wrong, he says, will “considerably exceed the initial franchise fee paid by that franchisee”.
Andy describes the same moment from the franchisor’s chair. Money has been going out for months, the first candidate arrives with a cheque for £15,000, “and human nature takes over”. He would not have given that person a job. His firm has a saying for it: “the first three are your worst three.”
Ken has seen what follows. “Usually the franchise stalls”, because the franchisor’s time goes on firefighting. He tells of a young network of ten or twelve where the consultant had chosen every franchisee; within eighteen months it “literally fell apart, and he was left with one”.
Farrah Rose finds the same fault abroad, where the brands that do well have “the discipline to choose the right partner” over the first one to knock on the door.
There is a practical reason on top of the cost. Clive and Ken both point out that the first few franchisees become the evidence the next ones ask to see.
4. How fast will the network grow?
Nobody would give a single figure, and they explained why.
Clive says it depends on the kind of business. With a low-cost, van-based franchise at four or five thousand pounds, “you could probably sell a couple a month, once you get yourself properly organised”. One that needs premises moves at the speed of finding premises and people with the funds.
Ken’s view is that the first two or three years set the pace for everything after. Get those right and a network “can move quickly, if the resources are there”: one of his clients went from ten or twelve franchisees to just short of a hundred in three to four years. He also gives the warning. A franchisor who was “absolutely flying” took on the franchisees’ leases to keep recruitment moving. When trade turned, the franchisees couldn’t pay the rent and the franchisor had to wind the business up.
5. How do I set the fee?
Liam Wilson, an accountant who acts for both franchisors and franchisees, says most people begin in the wrong place. “Don’t begin by asking what percentage competitors charge.” Work out what support you are promising, what it costs to deliver as the network grows, and what a reasonably performing franchisee can pay and still make a return. Only then look at the market.
He is equally firm that the percentage is not where the arguments come from. “Saying, for example, ‘8% of turnover’ is not precise enough.” Before or after VAT? What about refunds, bad debts, vouchers? Is the fee due when the customer is invoiced or when they pay? Whatever the answer, it has to read the same in the agreement, the manual, the accounts and the fee report.
Ken adds a rule about the other fee, the one paid at the start: it “should really cover all of the cost of supporting those franchisees, rather than dipping into the management fee”.
And there is a caution from Liam that the standard model hides: “turnover is not the same as profitability”. A franchisee whose sales are rising can still be getting weaker.
6. How will I know what is going on in the network?
Each guest came at this from their own trade, and the answers fit together.
Clive starts with the franchisor’s right to know. “Your systems must be intrusive.” Every franchisee should have a business plan, updated each year, and the franchisor should be reading the financials. He has had clients who “didn’t really like to ask”. His reply: “It’s in the agreement.”
Liam describes how to collect that information so that nobody has to be asked. The easiest model is one common system with the fee calculated from it automatically, and the franchisees told “what data head office can access, why it is collected, how the fee is calculated”. When the figures don’t match, franchisors “need to not treat every discrepancy as dishonesty”. Establish the facts first.
John Pratt, a franchise lawyer, adds a note of realism about cash businesses. Some of the takings will go undeclared, it is hard to prove, and “you sort of need to be grown-up about it”.
Tom Hill is our own technical director, so weigh his view accordingly. He speaks for the franchisees’ side of it. If a system gives head office visibility and gives the franchisee only more admin, it builds resentment. The cheapest way to be welcome is to take a chore away: “that thing you used to do, you don’t have to do any more.”
7. What happens when it goes wrong?
John’s first observation is that it mostly doesn’t, where the franchisees are earning. “If you’ve got franchisees who are making money, generally you don’t get disputes.”
When it does, his advice runs against instinct. Even a franchisor who is in the right should offer a commercial deal on the way out, because the alternative is court: an injunction costs “£30,000 plus”, and the costs don’t come back at that stage. Mediation settles 80 to 90 per cent of cases for something between £1,000 and £5,000 a day. He is unconvinced by the idea of making an example of one franchisee to warn the rest, and blunt about who gains from it: “The only people who win in litigation are franchise lawyers.”
He also warns that the standard clause stopping a former franchisee from competing for twelve months no longer holds as written since the Drain Doctor decision, and needs redrafting.
Clive gives the reason all this matters so much in franchising: the agreement runs for five, ten, sometimes twenty years, and “it’s not so easy to shift them if it’s not going well”.
Tom adds the practical side. The agreement can say the customer list belongs to head office, but if each franchisee keeps it in their own account with a software company, “all of the legal terminology in the world” won’t get it back, because that company’s contract is with the franchisee who left.
8. What changes for me?
More than most founders expect, according to all of them.
Andy calls it a two-hat role. The original business carries on, and beside it there is now a second one whose job is recruiting and coaching. Of franchisees he says: “they’re not staff. You can’t really wield the stick like you would do with a member of staff.”
Clive has met owners who saw franchising as “a route to semi-retirement”. His answer: “Franchising is absolutely not that.”
Ken recalls a business where the model was perfect and the founder “so autocratic it just would never have worked”. That one didn’t go ahead.
Farrah passes on something a client, Paul Thompson of Water Babies, once said to her: “One day I woke up and I found myself responsible not just for my family, but for two franchisees and their families, and for the two franchisees’ employees and their families.”
Where they agree, and where they don’t
Three things came up again and again without our asking. Franchise what already works. Choose the first franchisees as if you were hiring them, and turn down the cheque if they don’t fit. And keep the franchisees profitable, because most of the other problems, from late fees to lawyers, follow from franchisees who aren’t.
The differences are about how hard to press. Clive would have a franchisor insist on its rights to information; John would have it let some things go; Liam would rather the system made the question unnecessary. A new franchisor will have to decide where they stand between those, and it is better decided before the first agreement is signed than after the first argument.
There is a good deal we haven’t covered yet: the franchise agreement itself, selling a franchised business on, and the view from franchisors who have done all this. We are arranging those conversations now. If you have run a network, or advise the people who do, and would be willing to be recorded for twenty minutes, we’d like to hear from you.
All seven conversations, with audio and full transcripts, are in Expert interviews.